
The Type Of Alarm System
NOTE: THE FOLLOWING IS COPYRIGHT 2008 BY James Bell Jr. - Originally written in 2000.
ALL RIGHTS ARE RESERVED.
An alarm system, properly installed and used - meaning that you leave it armed, even while you are home - can give you those extra seconds, especially useful in the case of a home invasion robbery.
Many people don't understand that alarm systems can be used even while they are home.
Most systems allow the user to bypass the interior sensors - including motion detectors - while leaving the outer perimeter [outside-leading doors and windows] armed.
The most obvious way to automate facility security is through the use
of an electronic security alarm system. There are many different
types of alarm systems, installation techniques, and monitoring
methods, each with its own advantages and problems. There are
also local police jurisdiction requirements and responses to worry about.
When I talk with someone about installing an alarm system, the main
question I like to ask is "What do you want to happen when
the alarm is triggered?". This is really why people install
an alarm system. They want something to happen when the alarm
perimiter is breached. Ideally, they want the intruder to run off and
not continue to try and enter the facility. This is also where
monitoring and police response really come into play. If you want the
police to respond when your alarm is triggered, you will need to have
it monitored by an alarm monitoring company. It is not legal to have
your alarm call 911, or any other voice-type emergency response
number. If it does you can be fined or jailed. You need to go
through an alarm monitoring company for this kind of response.
Alarm monitoring companies have special receivers that accept calls
from professional-type electronic alarm panels. When you establish an
account with a monitoring company, they will program their systems
and your alarm to communicate with each other. When your alarm calls
them, it transmits an identification code and a series of
informational codes. These codes tell the alarm monitoring station
which alarm is calling them and why it is calling them, including
specific information on the zone or zones that were breached.
Most professional alarm panels can trigger on burglary, panic, and
fire [using the appropriate types of sensors] and can call the
monitoring company for any of these situations. The alarm monitoring
company then responds by calling the police or fire department and
informing them that have received an automated alarm call. Some
monitoring companies also have their own response personnel who can
go out to the site of the problem and seal the building, reset the
alarm, and perform any other temporary repairs if the owner is away.
Some also offer armed security response, but be prepared to pay
big-time for this service.
The major problem with alarm monitoring is that some police
departments will not even respond to a call when an alarm goes off. I
checked with several different jurisdictions in my area and in
others. With increases in personal and family violence and other
crimes, police have limited availability to respond to alarm calls.
In Los Angeles, CA dont even hope for a response from the
police to an alarm call. In Portland, Oregon, the police will respond
to the call, but will do so at a lower priority than a call from an
individual to 911. In Washington County, Oregon, the Sheriffs
Department will also respond to the call. They respond to a panic
alarm at a higher priority than an normal burglary call, but their
response to both is relatively fast. They do have an alarm permit fee
of $16.00 per year, as do many other locations. In Utah, many cities
won't respond directly to an alarm. They want the monitoring company
to send someone out first.
If you will have your alarm monitored, you need to have a permit if it is required in your area. Some police departments won't respond unless you do. Some jurisdictions also charge a fee if they respond to a call that was a false alarm or to an alarm that has no permit.
I am in favor of having your alarm monitored, but be aware that your local police may or may not respond. Sometimes they will respond faster to a neighbor calling to report an audible alarm than they will to a monitoring company [a nuisance call may get a higher priority than an alarm!].
I am not in favor of police charging fees for alarm permits, but
there isn't much you can do about that.
With this information, it starts to become clear that an alarm
system is best used to make noise and attract the attention of those
immediately surrounding the facility it is protecting. Burglars
don't want to stick around when a bunch of people are staring at
them. The alarm should call as much attention to the facility as possible.
You also want it to make plenty of noise on the inside of the
facility. If an intruder on the inside can not hear what is going on
outside, he/she will be less likely to stick around and run the risk
of getting trapped by the police or by an armed facility owner. The
best answer to the question "What do I want to happen when my
alarm is triggered?" is "I want the intruder to flee the
area as fast as they can without any successful theft or cause of
harm to family/employees.".
If you really want to be secure, you need a real alarm. Im not
talking about the Radio Shack, K-Mart, and X-10-brand systems that
you see Consumer Reports writing about. (In general, these systems
are far too false-alarm prone and a professional can bypass them
easily). Im talking about the real alarm systems that you can
only buy from a professional alarm distributor or installer. These
can be installed by an alarm installer, or you can do it yourself.
All you need to know to install one is how to plan what to put
together, how to mount magnetic contacts, how to run low-voltage wire
in your attic/crawlspace/basement/walls, and how to connect wire. It
isn't rocket science, but it sometimes isn't easy. Professional alarm
systems offer numerous advantages. They...
can be configured in many ways, meaning that the odds of someone
successfully determining how to defeat the alarm system are lower
since they won't be able to know the exact configuration. Other
systems have only so many options.
Companies like Brinks, ADT, and others that often advertise on television advertise systems that on the surface look like a great deal. They offer the alarm system at a "reduced" rate, sometimes even for free now, but they get you for a lengthy monitoring contract which is often for a period of several years. Systems like these are not all they are cracked up to be. They install an elementary alarm panel, put magnetic sensors on your front [and sometimes] back doors, install a motion detector or two, and call your home protected. While this will deter inexperienced criminals, the experienced ones can defeat these systems quickly.
One fundamental problem with systems installed by these companies is that they rely FAR too much on the motion detectors. Remember, if an intruder comes in through an outside-leading door or window that does NOT have a magnetic contact on it, that intruder will not trigger the alarm until they are well inside your facility and are seen by the motion detector. This means that they breached the physical security layer, and are now a real threat to the safety and well-being of those inside the facility.
You are also often at the mercy of a response center that is located in another state. This itself presents a couple of problems.
Some police respond to calls from out-of-state alarm monitoring companies at an even slower pace than an alarm monitored by a local company. This is partially because the systems monitored by these companies tend to be more prone to false alarms. These centers also handle an incredible number of calls, again with many of them being false alarms. If your alarm cant get through or is is too far down in the queue, any response you would have received may be far too late.
This can be an even more critical problem when an earthquake hits a state like California. You can figure that most of the alarms these companies install will false-alarm during an earthquake. If they do, they call out to the monitoring company station. Your call, to that same station from your state when you have a real alarm, may never get through because of the calls from the impacted area.
I recommend that you find a good, local alarm monitoring company if you want to go that route. Make sure that you find out if they just monitor alarms or offer other services. Some paging and answering services also offer alarm monitoring services. Stay away from these. If your alarm calls, and an emergency call comes in for a doctor, that call takes priority and your call may go unanswered for quite some time.
A good, local monitoring company can also work with you to determine
a response plan. You can tell them when you will be gone so that they
call police immediately. If you are going to be home, you can have
them call you first. If you are being held up, a good monitoring
company asks the right yes/no questions to determine that. This can
reduce false alarms and in some cases may be a good idea. Most
monitoring companies also offer installation of alarms, and some will
even sell high-end alarm components to you so that you can
do-it-yourself. Local companies will also be familiar with the local
police jurisdictions and will know how to interact with them.
One thing you will need to keep in mind is that some alarm monitoring
companies want to lock out your ability to program your own alarm
system. They like to keep their phone numbers and communications
options a secret. This means that if you sign up with a company that
does this, they will change the dealer and user programming codes on
your alarm. You will be at their mercy if you wish to make any
changes. This is a question to ask of any monitoring company.
Before you opt to have your alarm monitored, give your local law
enforcement alarm department office a call to see if they respond to
alarms and at what priority level. Some of them even keep statistics
on false alarms other difficulties with alarm monitoring companies
that can help you make a decision on what company to use. The
Portland Police Department gave me a comprehensive listing on the
companies in that city.
Also, make sure to ask if any alarm permits are needed and what the
associated fees are. I dont personally agree with alarm permit
fees (you are telling the police exactly where a crime is happening
so that they can respond, yet you pay extra for that on top of the
taxes that you pay.. in effect you are paying extra to get the
protection you already pay for) but they do exist in some areas.
I recommend that you setup your system to make a thief as nervous as
possible. With that in mind, set up your alarm system to make as much
noise as possible, both inside and outside of the facility. I
recommend two horns for a single-story residence, one inside and one
or more outside, and three for a two-story residence, one on each
floor and at least one outside. In a business, you want to make sure
the alarm is loud in all interior locations, and that there are horns
on each outside wall..
The inside horn alerts anyone inside the facility of the emergency,
and also makes it almost impossible to hear what is going on outside
of the facility. If an intruder can not hear well enough to determine
if sirens are approaching, he/she is not going to want to stay
inside. Place the inside horn in a main hallway, high up on the wall
or ceiling. Aim it to an open area so that you get the best sound
coverage out of it. This is especially important if you want to use
the alarm for Fire/Smoke warning as well as burglary.
Your outside horn should be placed so that it is high up to reach a
large area, and is preferably out of sight. Behind an attic air vent
is a great place for it. It will block some of the vent, but the
sound is well worth it. If you can, get two for outside and aim one
to the street, the other toward the nearest neighbor.
Another trick that works well is to mount to 12V strobe lights,
connected to your alarm system, underneath the eaves over the garage
(in a home) or near the front door (in a business). Get one red
strobe and one blue strobe and hook them up to the alarm. When it
goes off, the strobes will help emergency response personnel identify
the structure. They will also be visible, as reflections, from inside
of your facility. An intruder will see that and will have to wonder
if the police are not already on their way. They will want to get
away even faster.
You will also want to make sure that you can control the alarm from
several locations in your home/business. Most professional alarms use
a keypad mounted on the wall for arming, disarming, panic, and other
functions. Put one by each entry/exit door, one in a main hallway,
and one in the master bedroom and/or office. This way you are never
far from a panic or shutoff button. Most keypads use 2-pair or 4-pair
wire. Run this to each location where a keypad is desired.
Make sure that you put hard-wired magnetic contacts on each
outside-leading door and window. This way there are no totally weak
links in the chain of protection. If someone opens any door or
window, they will have tripped the alarm. Some people worry that they
look bad and dont want a lot of wire visible. A good installer
(or a homeowner with some sense) can make a good looking
installation. There are designer contacts that come in colors to
match the frame or door, and with appropriate drilling, wire
placement, and wire color, the inch or two of exposed wire can be
made to match as well. You can even get contacts that are buried into
the door and frame so that they can not be seen at all. Even a
professional wont know they are there.
Magnetic contacts are usually connected to the alarm using 2 wires.
You can get creative and wire all of the windows/doors in individual
rooms or areas in series as what are called ZONES. This lets you
group logical areas together.
Id also recommend that you booby-trap some inside doors with
the recessed magnetic contacts, and create a separate zone for these
that can be armed when you are away, or turned off when you are home,
leaving the other zones on. Booby-trap doors to bedrooms or offices.
Once someone is inside (if they did get past the first (physical) and
outer-second (electronic) layers to even enter the facility) they
will trigger one of these for sure.
There are many manufacturers of magnetic alarm contacts. I currently
recommend Sentrol as I have had VERY good luck with their products.
There is a link at the bottom of the page showing one of their products.
As for motion detectors, I recommend that you think carefully. There
was a time when I did not recommend any of these because they are
usually prone to false alarms from drapes moving over an air vent or
things falling over in an earthquake. Most of them still are. Some
companies, however, are now using a dual technology system that looks
for both heat and motion before they see the situation as a trigger.
Napco makes a sensor that takes this one step further yet, and
changes what it is looking for before considering the situation to be
a trigger.
The Napco Advanced Adaptive C-100ST PIR/Microwave Dual Technology
Sensor uses a system that I first experienced at a Northwest Security
Conference back in the late 90's. I have since tested the unit myself
and found it to make my list of recommended components.
The PIR portion of the unit looks for changes in the heat signature
of an area. This part could be fooled by heating or AC which is why
many false alarms happen. But when it is triggered it activates the
microwave portion of the unit. This looks for motion. This piece
could be triggered by movement of curtains, or even by strong
vibrations such as from an earthquake, again a major cause of false
alarms. But with this unit, both pieces must be triggered at the same
time in order for the unit to see a problem and trigger to the alarm
panel. In addition, a built-in CPU adds some further intelligence. It
changes the number of zones that motion must pass through if there is
any question as to the motion being an intruder or just a curtain
blowing. If only one zone is triggered, it just sits and keeps
looking. If the motion shows the type of motion a moving body would
make and passes through the second zone, an alarm is triggered. The
sensor does this in a fraction of a second, so it isnt really
foolable. It is a neat little piece of hardware. These wire to the
panel with 4 wires. They can be surface mounted on the wall, or
recessed using a special cut in box that Napco makes. The latter
makes a slick looking installation.
You will also want to get some smoke and/or heat detectors. The alarm
panel that I found to be the best, as well as most other professional
panels, can handle smoke/fire warnings. These are also available from
many companies, and connect to the alarm via 2 or 4 wires, and this
is usually special fire-type wire rather than standard twisted-pair.
We will be evaluating different models in the near future.
As you can see, there is some wiring involved in setting up an alarm
system. You can have a professional do it for you, or you can do it
yourself. You need to be aware that you will need to use attic
crawlspaces or go under the house. If you are afraid of confined
spaces, bugs, or wasps, you may want to hire a professional.
If you do want to do it yourself, you will need a drill, drill bits
[long, flexible bits such as the Greenlee DiversiBit for pulling
wire], fish tapes, wallboard saw, extension cords, electrical tape,
wire nuts/ScotchLoks, screwdrivers, and a lot of patience.
You will also want to know as much as possible about the construction
of your home. If you have any photos of the structure as it was going
up, these will help you plan where you can and cant drill.
Alarm systems use all low-voltage wire so that is not too much of a concern.
These are some of the things that you will need to consider if you will be installing an alarm in your home or business. Make sure that you adhere to all of the appropriate rules and regulations as you do so. Dont cut any corners. Remember that the property, and even more importantly, the lives you save, are those of yourself and your family or co-workers.
We recommend Napco
panels and components. They are easy to install, easy to program, and
offer features which cost extra in just about every other brand of
alarm panel. They are reliable and they work!
Based on personal experience, and from those for whom I have
installed them, alarm systems are WELL worth the money and time
involved. If you dont think so, wait until the next time you
come home and think there might be someone in your home A properly
installed, professional quality system will let you know with one
look at the keypad (just put it by your door!). And of course, the
odds are that they either left when it was triggered, or they
didnt even try in the first place. You may never know how
effective the alarm really was, even as a deterrent.
-- James Bell, Jr. -JeepGunner / ATVGunner / HondaGunner